Jay Helps You
Move In The Right Direction

Start Property Search

Homes Search
Client
Thoughts

- Gary l rusterholz Lancaster ohio , Buyer

Jay worked very hard through a couple difficult problems that occurred and handled prodessionally with positve outcome extremely satisfied with Jay

- Deidre Rusterholz, Lancaster, Ohio , Buyer

Jay did a great job handling any issues we had with the seller and answered any questions we had.

Jay was very patient with all our questions and anytime a house came on the market he worked around our schedules to make sure we were able to view it as soon as possible.

- Joshua Newman - Lancaster , Buyer

Jay is awesome to work with he has been available when we need him. He has been quick and knowledgeable with any and all of our questions. Jay was on a business trip during the time he was gone we found a home we ended up falling in love with he was able to get us an agent to help us tour the home ... VIEW MORE TESTIMONIALS

- Nicole Newman- Lancaster Ohio , Buyer

This is my 2nd time I have called on Jay Mattlin to help my husband and I. He is an absolute gem to work with and I will recommend him to everyone. Thanks Jay!

- Michelle Johnson, Lancaster , Buyer

Jay was excellent all the way through the process. From listening to our needs, to finding us appropriate houses to look at, being timely with responses and finding people to help if he wasn't available. Everything about the experience was great! Would recommend the agency and Jay to anyone who is ... VIEW MORE TESTIMONIALS

- Melissa from Lancaster , Buyer

Jay was a guiding light in the storm of buying my first home. He knew so much about the complex area I was aiming to buy in, was quick to get the offer together, and kept me informed at every step of the way. He didn't flinch at my million questions and quelled my worries along the way. I can... VIEW MORE TESTIMONIALS

You loathe typical real estate agent bios. Don’t worry, I do too. They’re like cardboard — stiff, bland, and identical to every other bio out there. Instead of boasting ad nauseum about awards and accomplishments you’re not interested in, I’m taking the novel approach of actually giving you what you want — real answers to questions you’re probably wondering right now.

Will you return my calls and emails?

Yes. Without question.
I realize this is one of the major frustrations the general public has with dealing with agents. I get dozens of calls and emails daily, and I work hard to reply as quickly as possible. My goal is typically within one business day.

I’ve met many Realtors who are jerks. Are you?

Depends on who you ask. If you ask certain agents who have stood between my clients and
their real estate goals, they’ll probably say “yes”. A handful of people think I leave golden
footprints in the sand. Those are the two extremes, and most people’s opinion falls somewhere
in the middle. Here’s what I can tell you: I’m honest and candid. I take pride in being approachable and
friendly. And if you need a quick real estate brain, or a strong dose of honesty, you’re in the right
place. Loyalty to family, clients, and friends is one of my core values. Want to really find out if
I’m a jerk? Mess with one of those people.

Do you have experience doing exactly what I need?

Until you tell me what you need, there is no way of knowing.
These are “strong suits” of mine:

  • Working with new buyers
  • First time sellers
  • USDA / FHA
  • Investment and Rental properties
  • Property Management / Tenant Menagement

If your goal or situation isn’t represented on that list, don’t worry. Contact me anyway. If I can’t help, I can get you referred to an another agent who can.

What kind of work are you really good at?

On a personal level, I’m pretty good at making wine. My pomegranate Zinfandel is amazing I’m told. I’m also pretty good at kayaking, hiking, and in general being outdoors. I’m also really good at giving back to my community because community and culture is important to me and our long term well being as a race.

On a professional level, here are the skill-sets that I’ve developed over the years:

  • Listening. Unfortunately, it’s a lost art these days.
  • Detail oriented. I know everyone says this but I’m pretty obsessive and a bit of a perfectionist.
  • Organized. This is so important in real estate. Even a little disorganization can ruin a deal.
Jay Mattlin, Principal Broker, ePRO, AHWD, C-RETS, C2EX, PSA
JayMattlin
Principal Broker, ePRO, AHWD, C-RETS, C2EX, PSA
Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 03/13/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 03/13/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:42:58 PM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:38:22 PM EST) or Metrolist - RECOLORADO by MLSGRID (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:34:53 PM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:34:55 PM EST) or RealComp MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:32:07 PM EST) or Dayton MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:41:46 PM EST) or NORIS MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:39:27 PM EST) or IRES MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:32:40 PM EST) or Colorado Real Estate Network IDX (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 8:29:09 AM EST) or CBRMLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:40:08 PM EST) or Multiple Listing Service of Greater Cincinnati (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:40:34 PM EST) or Terrehaute MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:41:45 PM EST) or Pikes Peak REALTORR Services Corp (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:30:23 PM EST) or Stellar MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:31:55 PM EST) or NKY MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:36:53 PM EST) or Wrist MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:34:54 PM EST) or Firelands MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:11:54 PM EST) or LCAR MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 10:50:16 AM EST) or West Central MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 1:53:23 PM EST) or Fort Myers (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:41:15 PM EST) or Aspen/Glenwood Springs MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 12:30:01 PM EST) or Northern Nevada Regional MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:41:50 PM EST) or MLS NOW (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:37:53 PM EST) or Northern Great Lakes Association of Realtors (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:34:44 PM EST) or Mansfield MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:37:18 PM EST) or Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:37:13 PM EST) or Grand Junction MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:37:17 PM EST) or Knox County MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:38:30 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:37:38 PM EST) or Pueblo MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 1:44:41 PM EST) or Upper Peninsula MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:40:09 PM EST) or Greater Lansing MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:35:43 PM EST) or SEBAR MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 2:39:25 PM EST) or Water Wonderland MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 12:52:56 PM EST) or Eastern Upper Peninsula MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 1:59:36 PM EST) or Scioto Valley MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 1:02:35 PM EST) or Northern Michigan MLS (last updated Fri 03/13/2026 12:34:12 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Key Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: 1-877-539-7589 | Ohio Lic# REC.2010002888 6800 W Central Ave #B, Toledo, OH 43617 | Michigan Lic# 6505366134 8040 Summerfield Rd, Lambertville, MI 48144 | Indiana Lic# RC52400106 3029 W Smith Valley Rd #211, Greenwood, IN 46142 | West Virginia LIC# 010306 Erin Rickman, Broker. 410 Market St #3, Parkersburg, WV, 26101 | Colorado LIC# EC.100108419 603 Rood Ave, Grand Junction, CO 81501 | Nevada LIC# B.0146350.LLC 9190 Double Diamond Pwky, Reno, NV 89521 | Florida LIC# CQ1073507 16638 Mooner Plank Cir, Wimauma, FL 33598



Agent License Information:  Brokerage/Company License Number: REC.2010002888

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel