Jay Mattlin, Real Estate Broker with Key Realty

Subscribe and receive email notifications of new blog posts.




Divorce Toolkit | 7 Posts
Fairfield County | 19 Posts
For Buyers | 72 Posts
For Sellers | 50 Posts
Hocking Hills | 1 Posts
House Tips | 63 Posts
Investors | 2 Posts
Lancaster Ohio | 3 Posts
Market Insight | 42 Posts
Ohio Real Estate | 22 Posts
Plants | 24 Posts
Probate Toolkit | 12 Posts
Real Estate Life | 26 Posts
Uncategorized | 4 Posts
Weekly Snippet | 14 Posts
May
16

Growing up, the building on the corner of Cherry Street and Angle Street in Lancaster, there has literally always been a restaurant there. The first one I remember is Snead's and then Bib's and then nothing. It was strange to see this building sitting empty since I can always remember something with delicious food being in there.

One time, upon driving passed the Snead's building, I noticed activity going on in the building. The rumor was that the owners of Billy Crickets, which had closed earlier, were opening a new restaurant in the 100 year old building. Thus the Cherry Street Pub was born.

 

The first time we visited Cherry Street Pub, we were greeted by a very enthusiastic hostess who set the tone for the entire restaurant. Seriously, have you ever gone to a restaurant and the host is just thrilled to welcome you in? And I don't mean actually thrilled, I'm being facetious – Cherry Street Pub was the complete opposite. Because of how she greeted us, I was fine with waiting almost an hour for a table. Granted, it was a Saturday night at about 6 p.m.

The restaurant itself is very well lit and has some awesome decor. The decor on the walls ranges from local photos and art to movie posters and sculptures. There are regular tables available for seating, several booths, a bar, two seater tables and a very nice booth kind of closed off from the rest of the restaurant.

One of the coolest features of the restaurant is that an antique bar that originated at the Last Chance Saloon on Main Street in Lancaster in the early 1900's. The bar was moved to it's current location in 1938 when Johnny Johnson's Restaurant opened. The bar then survived through Snead's, Bib's and now Cherry Street Pub. It is pretty awesome that instead of building something new and modern, Billy and Lorena Smith built the entire restaurant around it.

I ordered the fish and chips and my boyfriend got the caramelized ham mac and cheese. I can tell you that this was the best fish and chips that I have had in Lancaster. By far better than anything you can get anywhere around here. Adam has gotten this same mac and cheese several times since this first time. We have watched the mac and cheese menu grow over the last couple of years and each one of them is amazing. I love the pulled pork mac and cheese. It sounds strange but it's delicious.

So let's talk about beer selection because really that is what we want on a Friday night after working all week, right? Cherry Street Pub has a great selection of craft beer as well as beer in bottles and cans. Their beer selection changes pretty regularly as well so that's a plus since we do not have someplace in Lancaster that has a nice variety of craft beers. Cherry Street Pub also has growlers available to take your favorite tap beers home with you. It was very nice that we were able to sample some of the beer before we ordered a glass as well.

We have been back to Cherry Street Pub many times since they opened. We always receive great food, drinks and service. It is always nice to have not just amazing staff but to also see the owners hanging out and checking on their customers as well. If you are up for a great atmosphere, great food, and amazing service, go check out Cherry Street Pub in Lancaster. They're open 11 a.m. until 11 p.m., seven days a week. It's well worth the wait!

Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 03/17/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 03/17/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:21:48 AM EST) or MichRic (Michigan Regional Information Center) (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:17:19 PM EST) or Metrolist - RECOLORADO by MLSGRID (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:34:26 PM EST) or NIRA MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:04:55 PM EST) or RealComp MLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:15:42 AM EST) or Dayton MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:46:32 PM EST) or NORIS MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:14:13 PM EST) or IRES MLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:17:01 AM EST) or Colorado Real Estate Network IDX (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 7:05:51 PM EST) or CBRMLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:19:26 AM EST) or Multiple Listing Service of Greater Cincinnati (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:53:38 PM EST) or Terrehaute MLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:16:30 AM EST) or Pikes Peak REALTORR Services Corp (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:15:11 AM EST) or Stellar MLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:13:39 AM EST) or NKY MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:28:18 PM EST) or Wrist MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:24:19 PM EST) or Firelands MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:11:18 PM EST) or LCAR MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 10:50:11 AM EST) or West Central MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 9:50:01 PM EST) or Fort Myers (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:05:53 PM EST) or Aspen/Glenwood Springs MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 9:30:39 PM EST) or Northern Nevada Regional MLS (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:16:39 AM EST) or MLS NOW (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:17:34 AM EST) or Northern Great Lakes Association of Realtors (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:19:13 AM EST) or Mansfield MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:47:20 PM EST) or Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of Realtors (last updated Tue 03/17/2026 12:06:16 AM EST) or Grand Junction MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:37:09 PM EST) or Knox County MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:08:13 PM EST) or IRMLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:11:54 PM EST) or Pueblo MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:43:57 PM EST) or Upper Peninsula MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:10:08 PM EST) or Greater Lansing MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 10:36:16 PM EST) or SEBAR MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:39:19 PM EST) or Water Wonderland MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 10:52:35 PM EST) or Eastern Upper Peninsula MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 11:59:09 PM EST) or Scioto Valley MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 10:02:35 PM EST) or Northern Michigan MLS (last updated Mon 03/16/2026 9:33:54 PM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Key Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility

Agency License Information: 1-877-539-7589 | Ohio Lic# REC.2010002888 6800 W Central Ave #B, Toledo, OH 43617 | Michigan Lic# 6505366134 8040 Summerfield Rd, Lambertville, MI 48144 | Indiana Lic# RC52400106 3029 W Smith Valley Rd #211, Greenwood, IN 46142 | West Virginia LIC# 010306 Erin Rickman, Broker. 410 Market St #3, Parkersburg, WV, 26101 | Colorado LIC# EC.100108419 603 Rood Ave, Grand Junction, CO 81501 | Nevada LIC# B.0146350.LLC 9190 Double Diamond Pwky, Reno, NV 89521 | Florida LIC# CQ1073507 16638 Mooner Plank Cir, Wimauma, FL 33598



Agent License Information:  Brokerage/Company License Number: REC.2010002888

Login to My Homefinder

Pixel